As a business owner, you’re well aware of the vital role contracts play in the successful operation and growth of your company. Far too often, though, one or more parties may fail to follow through on their commitment. When a breach of contract arises, your business, your reputation, and your livelihood may suffer. Find out how an experienced legal team can help you fight for the results you deserve.
Our attorneys at Detroit Legal Group PLLC are prepared to help you seek a solution to your contract dispute, whether it involves an out-of-court settlement or litigation. Let us take on your legal burden while you focus your energy on what matters most: running your business. Contact our office in Detroit when you need skilled counsel in Dearborn, Warren, or Southfield, Michigan.
Types of Contract Breaches
After a contract is signed, all involved parties are bound together for a set period of time. Far too often, however, one or more parties may deviate from the terms set forth in the agreement, inciting a breach of contract. There are five categories commonly used to describe breaches of contract:
- Minor breaches
- Material breaches
- Anticipatory breaches
- Fundamental breaches
- Actual breaches
Our contract attorneys are prepared to explain the type of breach you’re facing as well as outline potential next steps. Schedule a free consultation with us today to get started.
Elements of a Breach of Contract Claim
In order for your claim to qualify as a breach of contract in a court of law, you must be able to prove the existence of three elements:
- Proof of the existence of a contract. The courts will require concrete evidence that a contract exists, and it may not be as simple as a handshake, a verbal agreement, or even a signed document. You will have to prove there was (a) an offer, (b) an acceptance of the offer, and (c) consideration was given in the interest of accepting the offer.
- Proof that the opposing party failed to perform or provide their obligations and that they did not have a substantial reason for not doing so
- Proof that the other party’s failure to perform or provide resulted in damages
If your claim meets all three of these qualifications, you may have grounds for legal action and should seek the help of an attorney.
Contract Dispute Attorney in Detroit: Remedies for a Broken Agreement
When a breach is proven, the usual goal is to put the injured party where it would have been if the contract had been performed as promised. Depending on the agreement and the facts, the remedies available may include:
- Compensatory damages for the direct loss, such as an unpaid invoice or the extra cost of hiring someone else to finish the job
- Consequential damages for foreseeable losses that flow from the breach, such as lost profits, when they can be proven with reasonable certainty
- Specific performance, a court order requiring a party to do what it promised, typically reserved for unique property such as real estate
- Rescission, which unwinds the contract and returns the parties to where they started
- Liquidated damages, when the contract sets a reasonable amount in advance for a particular breach
The party that suffered the breach is generally expected to take reasonable steps to limit its losses, such as finding a replacement supplier, rather than letting the damages grow. Choosing the right remedy early shapes how the demand letter is written, what evidence is gathered and what a fair settlement looks like.
Sale of Goods Contracts and the Uniform Commercial Code
Contracts for the sale of goods, such as inventory, equipment, parts and raw materials, follow Michigan's version of Article 2 of the Uniform Commercial Code rather than the general contract rules alone. One important difference is timing: a lawsuit for breach of a contract for the sale of goods generally must be filed within four years after the breach occurs, even if the buyer did not know about it yet. The parties can shorten that period in their original agreement to as little as one year, but they cannot extend it, so the fine print in a purchase order or supply agreement matters. Ali A. Berro, whose contract work covers real estate, construction, business and UCC law, can review how those terms apply to your dispute.
DEFENSE FOR YOU & YOUR BUSINESS
Defenses for Breach of Contract
When it comes to your breach of contract case, it’s important to be aware of defenses the other side may use. Most will involve affirmative defenses, which focus on proving mitigating circumstances that led to the contract breach. The defendant may try to prove:
- The contract was supposed to be in writing.
- There is a mistake in the contract.
- The contract terms weren’t agreed on or finalized.
- He or she lacked the capacity to contract.
- He or she was fraudulently induced to enter into a contract.
- The contract is egregiously unfair.
- The contract is illegal.
The defendant may also assert a right that contradicts what was said or agreed upon in the contract. At Detroit Legal Group PLLC, we’ve witnessed a variety of defenses over the years, and we’re able to use what we’ve learned to prepare you for your case.
Breach of Contract Lawyer in Detroit Courts: Where Your Case Is Heard
Where a contract lawsuit is filed depends largely on how much money is at stake and where the parties do business. Michigan's district courts have exclusive jurisdiction over smaller civil claims, up to a limit set by state law; in Detroit, that is the 36th District Court at 421 Madison St. Larger claims, and cases asking a court to order a party to act, are filed in circuit court. For Wayne County, that is the Third Circuit Court, whose Civil Division sits in the Coleman A. Young Municipal Center at 2 Woodward Avenue. Our guide to Detroit courts lists these courthouses, and a dispute with a company elsewhere in Wayne County may belong in that community's district court instead.
The Wayne County Business Court
Michigan law requires every circuit with at least three circuit judges to have a business court for business and commercial disputes, and the Business Court docket began in Wayne County Circuit Court on July 1, 2013. Business Court cases must be filed electronically and are assigned by blind draw to the business court judges. For companies, that means a contract dispute may be heard by a judge who regularly handles commercial cases, and the filing has to be prepared with that court's procedures in mind.
Civil Litigation Lawyer in Detroit: From Demand Letter to Judgment
A breach of contract claim does not have to start with a lawsuit, and many disputes can be resolved at an earlier stage. A typical path looks like this:
- Reviewing the contract, amendments, change orders, invoices and correspondence
- Preserving emails, text messages and other electronic records before they are lost
- Sending a written demand that explains the breach and what will resolve it
- Negotiating, or using mediation or arbitration when the contract calls for it or both sides agree
- Filing suit, exchanging evidence in discovery and preparing for trial
- Enforcing a judgment once the court enters one
A dispute can settle at any of these stages. What matters is that each step builds a record that supports your position if the case does go to a judge or jury.
Real Estate, Construction and Business Contract Disputes
Contract disputes rarely stay in one category. A failed closing can turn on the terms of a purchase and sale agreement, a construction project can stall over a disputed change order, and a supplier relationship can fall apart over a late shipment. Ryan Hill, the firm's founding member, focuses on business, construction and commercial litigation and real estate law, and attorney Clayton P. Miller handles civil litigation along with business and corporate law.
Because our attorneys also draft agreements, we look at a dispute the way a careful drafter would: what the words say, what they leave out and how a court is likely to read them. If you are entering a new agreement, our contract drafting attorneys can help prevent the next dispute, and our real estate attorneys handle the property side of a deal. To talk about a contract that has already gone wrong, schedule a free consultation or call (313) 306-8466, Monday through Friday from 9 to 5.
Questions for Our Breach of Contract Attorneys in Detroit, MI
Is a verbal agreement enforceable in Michigan?
Many verbal agreements are enforceable, but proving their terms can be difficult. Michigan law also requires certain agreements to be in writing and signed by the party being held to them, including an agreement that cannot be performed within one year, a promise to pay someone else's debt and an agreement to pay a commission on the sale of real estate. Contracts for the sale of goods above a price set in Michigan's Uniform Commercial Code generally need a signed writing as well.
Can I recover my attorney fees in a breach of contract case?
Usually each side pays its own attorney fees. The main exceptions are a contract that includes a fee-shifting clause and a statute or court rule that allows fees in particular circumstances. Check your agreement for a fee provision before a dispute begins, since it can change the economics of the case.
What if the contract says disputes must go to arbitration?
An arbitration clause generally means the dispute will be decided by an arbitrator instead of a judge or jury. Courts usually enforce these clauses, though questions about whether a clause covers a particular dispute, or whether it was validly agreed to, can be raised in court. The clause may also set the location, the rules and how the arbitrator is chosen.
Should my business keep performing after the other side breaches?
It depends on how serious the breach is. A material breach may excuse your own performance, while a minor breach usually does not, and stopping work over a minor breach can make your business the party in breach. Before you stop paying, delivering or working, have an attorney review the contract and the facts.
What should I bring to a consultation about a contract dispute?
Bring the signed contract and any amendments, change orders, purchase orders, invoices, payment records and the emails or letters about the problem. A short timeline of when the issue started and what each side has done since then helps an attorney evaluate your options quickly.
How We Can Help
You’ve worked hard to build a business you’re proud of. Don’t let a breach of contract get in the way of its success. Let us help you pursue a fair result. Our team is here to explain your options, from mediation to arbitration to litigation. Get started on a path forward by contacting our office in Detroit, Michigan. Since 2007, we’ve represented clients throughout the area, including residents of Dearborn, Southfield, and Warren. Schedule your free consultation today.
BREACH OF CONTRACT ATTORNEYS SERVING DETROIT, MICHIGAN
When a vendor or business partner doesn’t follow through on an agreement, you deserve to hold them accountable. As your breach of contract attorneys, we understand you want to put this issue behind you. Let us lead the way. Contact us for representation in Detroit, Michigan, or the surrounding area.
